Almost everyone assumes the same thing: as long as the content remains online, the damage continues, and as long as the damage continues, a claim can be made. It's a reasonable intuition. And for the most part, it's false.
The Supreme Court made it clear when ruling on a case that it's worth recounting slowly, because it can happen to anyone.
What happened
For years, a man had been suffering a smear campaign on the internet. It wasn't an isolated comment or someone having a bad day: it was successive posts on a personal blog and other websites, sustained between 2008 and 2014, with a clear pattern of wanting to harm him and the institution he was linked to.
He filed the claim in April 2021. The content, incidentally, was still there.
She lost. Not on the merits, nor because the court considered it acceptable, but because she was late.
The four years, and since when do they count
Article 9.5 of Organic Law 1/1982 states that actions to defend honour, privacy, and one's own image become time-barred after four years. What it does not state, and where everything hinges, is from when this period begins to count.
The Supreme Court's ruling distinguishes two situations.
If it's about a one-off publication —an article, a forum post, a blog post—, the period starts running from when it was published. Its continued accessibility on the internet five years later does not restart anything nor freeze the clock. The damage occurred upon publication; its online permanence is a consequence, not a new injury every morning.
If what there is a campaign, with successive publications and a clear unity of purpose, then it is considered continuing damage, and the time limit starts with the last publication of that sequence. Which is exactly what was discussed in this case: the last entry that was part of the campaign was in May 2014, so the time limit expired in May 2018. The claim arrived almost three years late.
The court's reasoning is coherent, even if it hurts: if the clock stopped until the content was deleted, the action would be in practice perpetual, because nobody ever deletes anything from the internet.
What is still alive
Here is the nuance that is lost in almost all summaries of this doctrine, and it is the most important for someone reading this with a problem.
The expiry of the claim for damages does not mean you are left with nothing. The right to erasure — the right to be forgotten from Article 17 of the General Regulation Data Protection— it doesn't depend on that four-year deadline. You can request the de-indexing of content from 2011 in 2026 and you can get it, because what is valued there is something else: whether that information is still pertinent, current, and proportionate today, not whether you claimed on time.
In other words, you can lose the right to compensation and still retain the right to have it stop appearing when someone types your name on Google. They are two distinct routes, with two different timelines, and confusing them is what makes many people believe they have no recourse and do nothing.
The practical lesson
Hardly anyone makes a claim in the first month. It's normal: it's hard to acknowledge the harm, you first try to talk things through, you think it will just go away on its own, you put the matter aside because opening it up hurts. You tell yourself you'll look at it later, and later turns into two years.
The problem is that those two years are not free. They eat up half the timeframe, and by then the evidence has deteriorated, witnesses have changed jobs, evidence has been lost from old mobile phones, and content has been replicated on sites no one controls anymore.
There's no need to sue tomorrow. But it is advisable, very soon, to do two low-cost things: make a documented record of what has been published and the date, and find out where you are in the timeline. With that, you can calmly decide whether or not to claim. Without it, the calendar might end up making the decision for you.




